Overall positive, but there are a few things to consider that might be negative.First they are pretty big - That may be a plus to some, and a minus to others.Pros:Delicious to open. The presentation is spot on! Packaging/storage container is so cool: looks almost like a specimen box which shows the earrings at their best (see photo).They are vivid colors, much like a real butterfly wing. Very eye catching.They are lightweight, which is important especially for earrings this large.Cons:Don't care for the fake leather. These might be a lot prettier if they were somewhat translucent.The edges (see my photo) of the wings are just the raw synthetic material. Would have been better if they were at least black to hide the base-foam color and make them look more realistic. Could maybe touch them up with a sharpie, but might that bleed? I say that to say I wish the edges were properly colored too. The unfinished edges are what really made me dock a star in the rating.Overall:If you like the look, and can tolerate the unfinished edges, get them. They look interesting and unique.